Request a Consultation
312-981-4440 Consultation
Peter Geldner, MD Why Credentials Matter Blog Hero Image

Why Credentials Matter: The Importance of Vetting your Plastic Surgeon

Carlos Hernandez-Fernandez, a Colorado surgical assistant, was arrested and sent to prison for pretending to be a plastic surgeon. Why is it shocking and why is this so common?

Con men have had active business for as long as there’s been human history. All you need is a good pitch, a susceptible audience, the right price, and the world is yours for the picking. The most common are not so brazen as to perform surgical procedures on unsuspecting patients. The more common story is when patients get facial and buttock fillers from some provider in a hotel room near the airport. The people who come to me, clearly harmed, swear that the injector was a doctor in their own country.

So, what does it take to con somebody? A good story; a low price; or just incredible self-confidence?

The Long Road to Becoming a Plastic Surgeon

Let’s take a dive and ask the question; what does it take to be a licensed plastic surgeon in the United States?

  • College: Not only do you have to get into college, but you have to be able to perform well on standardized exams, and through excellent grades and exam scores and recommendations get accepted into a medical school.
  • Medical School: Once in medical school you have to perform very well, achieving high test scores, good grades, and strong recommendations to get accepted into a residency program.
  • Residency: Residency programs in the specialty of plastic surgery range between five and seven years; but that’s just the beginning.
  • State Licensing: You then must obtain a state medical license. Most state medical licenses are issued as physician and surgeon. Pathologists hold the same license as a neurosurgeon. This practice goes back to the day when your family doctor would deliver the baby and take out an appendix and essentially do everything. Specialists were rare.
  • Board Certification: Board certification is yet another hurdle. Though the timing of specialty board examinations varies, the process is often complete by the second year of practice.

This is an intense, multi-year process requiring rigorous training, examination, and demonstrated competence.

Why the Danger?

In this case the gentleman was not even a doctor, but a surgical assistant. It’s very likely that Mr. Hernandez-Fernandez learned on the job. Perhaps he had some medical training in the past. But what do we know? Clearly, he did not go through the training and the examinations and the proof of competence that a surgeon has to achieve, but he had a smooth voice, a convincing demeanor and possibly the right price.

How Patients Can Protect Themselves

So, what does it take for a potential patient to make sure that they’re getting the real deal? Clearly, you have to find out something about the person who is holding themselves out to be a plastic surgeon.

  • Research your surgeon’s education and training.
  • Ask what specialty their residency was in.
  • Look up hospital and academic affiliations.
  • Verify their medical license online.
  • Read reviews and ask for personal recommendations.
  • Review before and after cases.
  • During your consultation, don’t hesitate to ask to see diplomas or certifications—many surgeons proudly display them.

It’s not unfair to ask tough questions. It’s your body and your health on the line. Making your surgeon a little uncomfortable is far better than being deceived by someone unqualified. Ultimately what you’re doing is trying to make sure that you are seeing an excellent plastic surgeon and that you’re not getting hoodwinked.

Frequently Asked Questions About Plastic Surgeon Credentials

Why do plastic surgeon credentials matter?

Credentials matter because surgery is not a casual service. It is not a haircut, a facial, or a simple purchase from a menu. Surgery involves anesthesia, anatomy, judgment, sterile technique, complication management, and long-term follow-up. A qualified plastic surgeon has gone through years of education, residency training, licensing, and examination before operating independently.

What does it take to become a plastic surgeon?

In the United States, the path is long by design. A plastic surgeon completes college, medical school, and then a residency program in plastic surgery, which typically takes five to seven years. After that comes state licensing, board examinations, and continued professional accountability. That training is not just a formality. It is the structure that protects patients.

What does board certification mean?

Board certification means a surgeon has completed an approved training pathway and passed examinations in that specialty. For plastic surgery, patients should look for certification by the American Board of Plastic Surgery. There are many boards and many impressive-sounding titles, so the exact board matters.

Is every “cosmetic surgeon” a plastic surgeon?

No. This is where patients can get confused. A physician may call himself or herself a cosmetic surgeon without completing a plastic surgery residency. Some may have training in another specialty. Some may have taken courses. That does not make them a plastic surgeon. The title can sound similar, but the training may be very different.

How can I verify that my surgeon is properly trained?

Ask direct questions. Where did you go to medical school? What residency did you complete? Are you board-certified, and by which board? Do you have hospital privileges? Is your license active and in good standing? A qualified surgeon should not be offended by these questions. In fact, most of us expect them.

Why are hospital privileges important?

Hospital privileges mean that a hospital has reviewed the surgeon’s credentials and has granted permission to perform certain procedures there. Even if your surgery is performed in an office or accredited surgical center, hospital privileges can be an important sign that another institution has reviewed the surgeon’s training and qualifications.

Should I ask to see diplomas or certifications?

Yes. There is nothing wrong with asking. Many surgeons display their diplomas, board certificates, and professional memberships in their offices. You are not being rude. You are being responsible. It is your body, your health, and your result.

Are online reviews enough when choosing a plastic surgeon?

Reviews can be helpful, but they are not enough. A charming personality and a collection of positive reviews do not replace training. Reviews should be one part of your research, along with board certification, licensing, before-and-after photos, hospital affiliations, and the quality of the consultation.

Why should I look at before-and-after photos?

Before-and-after photos help show a surgeon’s judgment, consistency, and aesthetic style. They also help you see whether the surgeon has experience with patients who have concerns similar to yours. Look for natural results, good lighting, consistent angles, and honest presentation. A gallery should educate you, not mislead you.

What are warning signs that a provider may not be qualified?

Be cautious if the provider avoids questions about training, offers unusually low prices, pressures you to schedule quickly, cannot clearly explain risks, or performs procedures in questionable settings. A smooth voice and confident sales pitch are not credentials. Neither is a social media following.

Is price a good way to choose a plastic surgeon?

No. Everyone has a budget, and cost matters. But surgery is not the place to shop for the lowest bid. A lower price may reflect lower overhead, less training, shortcuts in safety, or a setting that is not appropriate for the procedure. The most expensive surgeon is not automatically the best, but the cheapest option can become very expensive if something goes wrong.

What should I ask during a consultation?

Ask about the surgeon’s training, board certification, experience with your procedure, complication rates, facility accreditation, anesthesia, recovery, and what happens if there is a problem. Also ask to see results that are relevant to your anatomy and goals. A good consultation should make you more informed, not more pressured.

Can med spa procedures also require credential checks?

Absolutely. Injectables, fillers, lasers, and energy-based treatments may seem less serious than surgery, but complications can occur. Patients should know who is performing the treatment, who is supervising, what training they have, and what happens if there is a complication. The setting should feel medically responsible, not simply fashionable.

What is the best way to protect myself as a patient?

Do your homework. Verify the license. Confirm board certification. Ask about residency training. Review before-and-after photos. Look for hospital or academic affiliations. Read reviews carefully. Most importantly, trust your instincts. If someone does not want to answer reasonable questions, that is your answer.

What is the main takeaway about plastic surgeon credentials?

Do not be dazzled by a title, a price, or a confident presentation. Plastic surgery requires real training and real accountability. Patients have every right to ask tough questions before placing their health in someone else’s hands. A qualified surgeon will understand that. A questionable one may not.

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Want to learn more?

Name*